You don't think the Valar would have or could have blessed the Hobbits with immortality at that point?Sam Gamgee wrote:I bet Bilbo was dead. Frodo may or may not have been. But the rest, probably.
Search found 56 matches
- Sat Jan 29, 2005 10:21 am
- Forum: The books
- Topic: Sam Sails to the West....
- Replies: 29
- Views: 17851
- Fri Jan 28, 2005 3:28 pm
- Forum: The books
- Topic: Sam Sails to the West....
- Replies: 29
- Views: 17851
Sam Sails to the West....
In 61 FA, Sam sails into the West to the Undying Lands. How do you think he was met? What do you all think might have happened then? Did Frodo, Gandalf, Bilbo, Elrond, and/or Galadrial meet him there? I'm curious....
- Thu Jan 27, 2005 2:11 pm
- Forum: The books
- Topic: What Book would I Read....
- Replies: 5
- Views: 5164
- Thu Jan 27, 2005 8:01 am
- Forum: The books
- Topic: What Book would I Read....
- Replies: 5
- Views: 5164
What Book would I Read....
...If I wanted read about the evants and happenings in Dol Guldur? I have been reading around the Net about the White Council and such. I have been reading about how Sauron, after his defeat by the last alliance went to Dol Guldur and how the Mirkwood got its name from the shadow of evil from Sauron...
- Tue Jan 25, 2005 8:23 am
- Forum: The movies
- Topic: The Moment You Hated The Most...
- Replies: 22
- Views: 16032
the implication that WK would have wiped up Gandalf is absurd. I can't agree more... I liked the Theoden bit. Actually a highlight for me. He did a much better job of it than Aragorn did at the Gates. Steve I liked the Theoden pep talk too. I also liked the Aragorn pep talk before Battle of the Mor...
- Mon Jan 24, 2005 10:12 am
- Forum: The movies
- Topic: The Moment You Hated The Most...
- Replies: 22
- Views: 16032
The Moment You Hated The Most...
We all know that while the movies are based on the books, it's getting more and more difficult to compare the two; especially as I read further and further the trilogy. I picked it up after finishing The Hobbit a few weeks ago. I just see so much difference and so much that was omitted from the movi...
- Thu Jan 20, 2005 7:41 am
- Forum: The movies
- Topic: Spock + Bilbo + freaky dancer ladies
- Replies: 15
- Views: 12025
- Wed Jan 19, 2005 3:37 pm
- Forum: The movies
- Topic: Spock + Bilbo + freaky dancer ladies
- Replies: 15
- Views: 12025
- Wed Jan 19, 2005 3:28 pm
- Forum: The movies
- Topic: RotK Extended Edition
- Replies: 20
- Views: 14030
It. Needed. The. Scouring. Of. The. Shire. 'nuff said. We all knew after seeing the theatrical version that it wouldn't make it in. And as soon as we saw Grima pull the knife on Orthanc we double-knew. The Scouring of the Shire is too complex for this (any?) film adaptation. I think that the scene ...
- Mon Jan 17, 2005 8:00 am
- Forum: The books
- Topic: If The WitchKing had....
- Replies: 23
- Views: 15272
Let's go by the actual book Ug. Definitely. Why in the world does PJ have the Witch King break Galdalf's staff? THe only answers that I can come up with make NO sense. It also draws an erroneous parallel between Saruman, whose staff was broken when he was defeated and Galdalf whose staff is broken ...
- Mon Jan 17, 2005 7:49 am
- Forum: The books
- Topic: Witch-King of Angmar?
- Replies: 10
- Views: 7670
- Fri Jan 14, 2005 5:44 pm
- Forum: The books
- Topic: If The WitchKing had....
- Replies: 23
- Views: 15272
Sam, That was a very astute reply. I believe you're right. I read LotR about 15 years ago and sometimes my memory gets clouded with PJ's adaptation. I'm rereading the Sil currently and I hate to go back to LotR for any reference. I don't want to ruin my momentum. My apologies. Being a Gandalf the Wh...
- Fri Jan 14, 2005 3:00 pm
- Forum: The books
- Topic: If The WitchKing had....
- Replies: 23
- Views: 15272
If The WitchKing had....
Actually slain Gandalf (perish the thought) as he was about to do after he shattered his staff before the Rohirrim showed up, Would Gandalf had been sent back? He was sent back after his fateful battle with Durin's Bane as Gandalf the White. he was sent back because he hadn't finished his task. Woul...
- Fri Jan 07, 2005 1:08 pm
- Forum: The books
- Topic: Witch-King of Angmar?
- Replies: 10
- Views: 7670
- Wed Jan 05, 2005 12:55 pm
- Forum: The books
- Topic: Witch-King of Angmar?
- Replies: 10
- Views: 7670